Jimmy John’s New Toasted Pizza Sandwiches: A Warm Twist on Classic Subs
Jimmy John’s is stepping into new territory with its latest release — the Toasted Pizza Sandwiches. Known for fresh ingredients and quick service, the chain has now introduced subs that bring the flavors of a pizzeria right into a toasted sandwich.
Two variations are available for a limited time:
Both are served on fresh French bread, toasted until golden, with rich marinara and melted cheese. It’s comfort food that still carries the Jimmy John’s touch of simplicity and speed.
What’s Inside the New Toasted Sandwiches
The Sicilian Pizza Sandwich is bold and meaty. It’s built with layers of salami, capocollo, and ham. Melted mozzarella adds creaminess, while marinara sauce brings a tangy balance. A sprinkle of oregano and basil finishes the flavor.
The Three Cheese Pizza Sandwich is a vegetarian option but still feels indulgent. Mozzarella, provolone, and parmesan are stacked together, melted over marinara, and seasoned with herbs. It’s cheesy, gooey, and satisfying without any meat.
Both sandwiches lean on the familiar taste of pizza but come in a handheld toasted sub.
Taste and Texture
The first bite sets the tone. The toasted bread is crisp on the outside and warm inside. The Sicilian has a layered richness — salty, smoky meats paired with creamy mozzarella. Every chew feels hearty and filling.
The Three Cheese, on the other hand, is pure comfort. Cheese pulls, smooth marinara, and toasted bread combine into a flavor that reminds you of a pizza night at home. It’s simple, but the seasoning makes it pop.
Price Breakdown
These toasted sandwiches are positioned as premium items on the Jimmy John’s menu. They can be ordered alone or as part of a combo with chips and a drink.
Here’s a breakdown of the pricing:
| Item | À La Carte Price | Combo Price (Sandwich + Side + Drink) |
|---|---|---|
| Sicilian Pizza Sandwich | $10.39 (starting) | $13.99 (starting) |
| Three Cheese Pizza Sandwich | $10.39 (starting) | $13.99 (starting) |
Prices may vary slightly depending on your location, but they generally fall within this range.
Nutrition Facts
If you’re counting calories or keeping an eye on sodium, the numbers matter. These sandwiches are indulgent and heavier compared to lighter subs. They deliver good protein but also come with higher sodium and fat.
Here are the details for the 8-inch size:
| Sandwich | Calories | Total Fat | Saturated Fat | Sodium | Carbs | Sugar | Protein |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sicilian Pizza Sandwich | 820 | 30 g | 15 g | 2,620 mg | 80 g | 6 g | 49 g |
| Three Cheese Pizza Sandwich | 830 | 32 g | 18 g | 2,010 mg | 79 g | 5 g | 47 g |
They are high in sodium, especially the Sicilian. But they also provide nearly 50 grams of protein, making them filling choices.
Comparing to Other Jimmy John’s Sandwiches
Jimmy John’s has been known for its cold subs for years, but toasted options are becoming more common. Earlier releases like the Chicken Bacon Ranch and Ultimate Italian already showed that fans enjoy warm, cheesy variations.
The Toasted Pizza Sandwiches push that trend further. Instead of leaning only on deli flavors, these sandwiches borrow directly from pizza culture. The marinara, mozzarella, and herbs make them feel like something new, yet familiar.
Pros of the New Sandwiches
Things to Consider
- High sodium: The Sicilian is especially salty. If you’re watching sodium intake, this is something to keep in mind.
- Calorie-dense: Both sandwiches are over 800 calories before adding chips or a drink.
- Saturated fat: With plenty of cheese, they lean heavy on fats.
For balance, you could pair the sandwich with a lighter side, like Jimmy John’s pickle or a smaller drink instead of chips.
Who Will Love These Sandwiches
These toasted creations are ideal for:
FAQs About Jimmy John’s Toasted Pizza Sandwiches
1. Are the Toasted Pizza Sandwiches permanent on the menu?
No, they are available for a limited time. Availability may vary by location.
2. Can I customize the sandwiches?
Yes, you can request extra toppings, skip meats, or adjust sauces depending on your store’s policy.
3. Which one is vegetarian-friendly?
The Three Cheese Pizza Sandwich is the vegetarian option. The Sicilian contains multiple meats.
4. How do they compare to Jimmy John’s regular subs?
They are heavier, warmer, and more indulgent. Regular cold subs are lighter, while these toasted sandwiches feel closer to comfort food.
5. Are they available for delivery?
Yes, you can order through Jimmy John’s app, website, or delivery partners in most areas.
6. What sides pair best with these sandwiches?
Because they’re rich, lighter sides like pickles or a simple salad balance them well. Chips and a fountain drink work if you want the classic combo experience.
7. Are they kid-friendly?
Kids who enjoy pizza flavors will likely love the Three Cheese option. The Sicilian might be a bit strong due to its salty, cured meats.
Final Thoughts
Jimmy John’s Menu new Toasted Pizza Sandwiches deliver exactly what their name promises: pizza vibes wrapped in a toasted sub. They’re not light meals, but they are flavorful, fun, and filling.
If you’re craving something warm and cheesy, these sandwiches will likely hit the spot. Just be mindful of the nutrition stats before making them an everyday choice.
Whether you go for the meat-packed Sicilian or the cheese-heavy vegetarian option, both deliver on comfort and taste. They’re limited-time items, so if you’re curious, it’s worth trying them while they’re still on the menu.
